About the NEB MMTP Hearings and Council of Canadians Winnipeg Chapter
The Council of Canadians - Winnipeg Chapter is an Intervenor in the National Energy Board hearings on Manitoba Hydro’s proposed Manitoba-Minnesota Transmission Project.
The MMTP would be “500 kV alternating current international power line (IPL) extending from Manitoba Hydro’s Dorsey Converter Station in Manitoba to the international boundary between Manitoba and Minnesota (Dorsey IPL). The Dorsey IPL will connect with the Great Northern Transmission Line, a new 500 kV transmission line in the United States.” NEB Project Description
The Chapter is concerned about many issues when it comes to Manitoba Hydro, including hydro justice for northern communities, the environmental devastation resulting from Hydro’s control of waterways in Manitoba, and the urgent need to transition away from fossil fuels.
As Intervenors in the MMTP hearings, we chose to focus on two specific problems that are relevant to the proposal: 1) Cathodic protection and 2) Transition.
There is a very specific process that must be followed for Intervenors and the Applicant (in this case, Manitoba Hydro) during an NEB hearing. The Information Request is the primary method for expressing concerns and asking questions about a project.
Once Manitoba Hydro replies to the Information Request, the Intervenor can either accept Hydro’s response or can take the next step by filing a Motion to Compel Full and Adequate Response.
“Motions are formal requests that require the Board to make a decision or an order.”
The Motion to Compel gives the reasons why the Intervenor is not satisfied with Hydro’s answers and asks the NEB to compel Hydro to take action.
The detailed and fully referenced Information Requests and all responses are part of the public record on the NEB Regulatory Documents website. Check out our blog for a less-detailed overview of our Information Requests.
_____________________________________________________________________Please complete a brief survey to let us know where you stand.Are you interested in transit, transition, and climate solutions? In the recent Made-in-Manitoba Climate and Green Plan, Manitoba committed to replacing fossil fuels with electricity. This plan is designed to meet Canada’s Paris Climate Agreement targets.
STANDING WITH INDIGENOUS COMMUNITIES
Shoal Lake 40 First Nation - Beyond Freedom Road
Winnipeg's decision to build an aqueduct from Shoal Lake had serious repercussions for the people of the Shoal Lake 40 First Nations community. They were dispossessed of land that included ancestral burial grounds as well as their village at the mouth of the Falcon River. Forced to move to the adjacent peninsula, they were completely cut off when that peninsula was subsequently severed from the mainland by a canal diverting coloured Falcon River water away from Winnipeg's intake. The community has struggled with its man-made isolation ever since.
The First Leg of Freedom Road from Shoal Lake 40 First Nation
The Council of Canadians is committed to an ongoing relationship with Shoal Lake 40. We support them in their reasonable demand for an end to the century-long isolation imposed by the City of Winnipeg's water infrastructure. Many lives have been lost and damaged by this man-made isolation, while Winnipeg has benefited and profited from the water.
In December 2015 the three levels of government finally announced the $30 million in funding to build Freedom Road, which will end more than 100 years of forced isolation. It’s good news and a positive step forward! The community has a right to clean drinking water and opportunity for its people. We would encourage those of us on the receiving end of Shoal Lake's water, including all levels of governments, to continue to work with Shoal Lake 40 for justice.
Lake St. Martin First Nation - Flooded and Displaced
In 2011 the Manitoba government diverted flood water bound for Winnipeg to the north and as a result, most of the Lake St. Martin First Nation (LSMFN), a reserve for 140 years and home to Anishinaabe people, was washed out. Since then the 1,064 LSMFN members reside in urban hotels and other temporary residences.
“The impacts from flooding and dislocation on LSMFN are profound and extensive. Environmental and developmental displacement has resulted in community members describing themselves as refugees in their homeland. Participants reported that health impacts in their community include premature deaths, increased rates of suicides, miscarriages, mental health issues, and worsening of chronic diseases such as cancer, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease. The impact on community members is also expected to be more profoundly negative and long lasting than those subjected to other community relocations because of their deep attachment to their land and loss of subsistence and resource livelihoods.” Lake St. Martin First Nation Community Members’ Experiences of Induced Displacement: “We’re like refugees” Refuge - Number 2, Volume 29
Relocation plans looked like they were heading forward, but the project has been marred by problems. The construction of a new community began in the spring of 2015 on the Halaburda land adjacent to the flooded reserve. But this property is also supersaturated, similar to the original reserve. Several feet of scrub and peat moss has to be dug out and foundations must be constructed, as well as a huge drainage system that must be run year-round. Now, Chief Adrian Sinclair is asking the federal government to investigate whether “inappropriate” behaviour on the part of Indigenous Affairs officials has deprived his people of a suitable community.
WATCH FULL DOCUMENTARY:
Flooding Hope: The Lake St. Martin First Nation Story
Treading Water: Plight of the 2011 Manitoba First Nation Flood Evacuees
Pimicikamak - The Agreement to Process signedWe stand with the people of Pimicikamak in their ongoing process with the Provincial Government and Manitoba Hydro.
Nearly 5,000 people live in the area, which is located over 700 kilometers north of Winnipeg. Local residents there say they have some of the highest electricity and heating bills in the province, despite the electricity generated from a dam in their own territory. The issue is much larger than just utility bills though. There are issues of treaty rights to land and a Northern Flood Agreement (NFA), which is not being implemented. The NFA is supposed to compensate northern Manitoba First Nations affected by hydro development.
Green Green Water 84:34
Grassy Narrows - From Mercury Poisoning to Mass Deforestation
Asubpeeschoseewagong First Nation (also known as Grassy Narrows First Nation) is an Anishinaabeg community located 80 km north of Kenora, Ontario.
In the 1960's the Dryden Chemical Company poisoned the English-Wabigoon River System with mercury from their effluent discharge. People from Grassy Narrows continue to suffer the effects of mercury poisoning more than 40 years after their commercial fishery was closed.
In 1985 the First Nation received a settlement agreement, which, by today's standards is inadequate. As well, the mercury has never been removed from the water and it continues to adversely affect the health of Grassy Narrows residents today.
Weyerhauser Forest Products has been harvesting trees in the area to supply its Timberstrand Mill in Kenora. The community is concerned about the mass extraction of trees for paper and fears that deforestation will irreversibly damage local habitat.